Awards

If I Had an Oscar Ballot 2025: A Year of Triumphs Amid Trying Times

Awards Circuit Column: It’s hard out there for iconoclastics hoping to become Oscar contenders. 

Hollywood’s state of flux extends beyond labor disputes and political tensions — it also colors how the industry evaluates its own output. A year inundated with big IP and musicals also was clouded with a lingering uncertainty about Hollywood’s future, and what narrative adventures it would continue to tell. 

“This year was shit,” a voting member of the Academy told Variety bluntly, referring to the overall movie year. However, another voter offered a starkly different take: “An extraordinary year for movies, and there’s more I still need to see.” 

Indeed, 2024 has been a year of soul-searching. Last year’s strikes upended production schedules and sparked debates about fair compensation. Meanwhile, Donald Trump’s reelection ignited fresh discussions about cultural identity and artistic resistance. Against this backdrop, many of this year’s films wrestled with themes of power, identity and survival — art imitating life in a deeply fractured time. 

Consider writer-director Mike Leigh’s latest opus, “Hard Truths,” an undeniably affecting drama about a British woman navigating a torrent of emotional duress. The 81-year-old auteur, known for his improvisational filmmaking style, and getting financiers to fund his vision without reading a single word of the script, defied conventional production standards to bring his project to life. 

“Hard Truths” is nearly universally acclaimed, boasting a 97% rating on Rotten Tomatoes and cementing its status as one of the year’s most lauded dramas.  

But it’s not just indie filmmakers overcoming the odds – smaller studios are doing what they can to stay on par with streaming companies. 

Even for a studio as cool as A24, known for championing auteur-driven work, the year was an uphill battle, with films like the boldly controversial “Civil War” struggling to reap box office returns. Where the studio has gained Oscar attention, it’s been with acquired titles like the Colman Domingo-led “Sing Sing” after its TIFF debut in 2023, and then picking up earlier this year, Brady Corbet’s $6 million historical epic “The Brutalist” and Luca Guadagnino’s period drama “Queer.” Even those acclaimed films weren’t box office winners in a market that often overlooks character-driven narratives.

Take Alessandra Lacorazza Samudio’s “In the Summers”: The Sundance sensation won the Grand Jury Prize and showcases a multigenerational cast of breakout talent, including star René Pérez. Yet it struggled to secure U.S. distribution, sitting in limbo for six months before Chicago-based Music Box Films stepped in. The boutique studio gave the film a limited theatrical release, followed by VOD — a modest rollout for a movie that should have been a slam dunk on the awards circuit. 

How can David conquer Goliath in today’s market?

For every headline-grabbing flop like the $200 million “Joker: Folie à Deux,” there sits in the shadows a daring passion project like “Nickel Boys.” The $23 million adaptation of Colson Whitehead’s Pulitzer-winning novel introduced the world to RaMell Ross’ visionary direction and has been embraced by critics. Then there’s Sean Baker’s “Anora,” the $6 million Cannes sensation about a stripper’s entanglement with a Russian oligarch’s son. It won the Palme d’Or, grossed over $25 million, and is a frontrunner for Oscar’s best picture prize.

Filmmakers like Baker, Ross and Leigh — and countless others fighting to tell stories that matter — prove that creativity is not easily silenced. In turbulent times, art continues to thrive.

As we sign off from 2024 and look ahead to 2025, this is the time of the year when our critics are weighing in on their best (and worst) films. Also, as part of the annual tradition, I’m including what my own Oscar ballot would look like if I were a voter. I disregard campaigns, criteria for eligibility in specific categories, and all the other factors that make art subjective. Many will disagree with these choices, but this list is mine (you can make yours, too). I’ve included recognition for casting directors, who will get their overdue spotlight at the 2027 season, along with deserved nods for stunts, first-time directors, and breakthrough performances.

Articles You May Like

Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs’ Legal Troubles, Explained: From ‘Freak-Offs’ to Sex Trafficking Charges to 120 Upcoming Lawsuits
Society of Composers & Lyricists Awards Noms Led by ‘Emilia Pérez’ and Atticus Ross; Harry Gregson-Williams and Ridley Scott Set for Collaborators Award
How ‘Squid Game’ Became a Business Empire for Netflix, and Why Its Creator Says ‘I’m So Sick’ of ‘Squid Game’
NATO Report Goes Beyond Box Office to Assess Strength of Theatrical Exhibition
‘12.12: The Day’ Review: South Korea’s Oscar Submission Is an Exciting Political Thriller About the Nation’s 1979 Coup d’Etat

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *